have you tried cerave yet? i just started using clean & clear makeup dissolving cleanser and really love it. i use it even when i dont have any makeup on. it gets your face really clean but not as dried out as neutrogena.

I hated Cetaphil but love Cerave. They have a foaming cleanser for oily skin, and a hydrating for normal to oily skin. The foaming one doesn't really foam up, but it really helped with the oil. I'm now using the hydrating cleanser because acne products have dried me out.