suelily

If you want to get rid of the shine during the day Boots sell Oil Absorbing sheets that you could carry around. I'm 43 and by midday my skin is shiny no matter what product I put on my face.

Try using benzoyl peroxide with clindamycin 1%. I find using these together better than benzoyl peroxide alone when my skin starts to flare up.

You already tried ACV which is what i would recommend. You could also use rose water mixed with essential oils of your choice. In actuality, toner in my opinion is not a necessary pary of a skin car...