Closed comedones. Inorder for them to dissapear they usually have to turn into full blown pimples (I have experience). Sometimes they may go away on their own, but it seems like yours are becoming inflamed the second stage. Only products that would work are BHA, Benzoyl Peroxide, Tretinoin but they would have to make everything deep inside come to a surface which means youll be experiencing a big breakout. I suggest cutting dairy and processed foods and sugars. Keep a balanced diet and research natural vitamin product instead of those chemically syntheized ones like d1-alpha is fake most brand companys use fake synthetic vitamins its post to be d-alpha. Research authentic natural vitamins a,e,c,zinc picolate, calcium and magnesium also omega 3 fish oils. When you shower dont let the dhamppo touch your face or let it run down your face always bend your head back. Dont touch your face ever. Hormones also plays a role into it also likely because your a female. I suggest going to a derm, but theres a high chance hell prescribe you with some topical application if he does I am telling you it will get worse before it get better. All those little bumps will come to a surface. Good luck