Switch to a gentle moisturizer with no active ingredients.

I have this exact same problem. I react to absolutely everything. I was going out my mind trying to find something that didn't leave my face red and itchy and the only line I can use is a brand called Pai. It's quite pricey but worth every penny in my opinion. I'd rather spend 34 on something than have damaged, irritated skin. I use the Geranium and Thistle moisturiser but they do a few different ones.

They do samples too for not much. x