Notifications
Clear all

cause and cure

MemberMember
1
(@mcmg)

Posted : 04/02/2011 12:57 pm

I had pretty severe acne starting in junior high and all through high school. It would go away and my skin would be clear on occasion, but I never noticed the nutritional cause of my acne was just a few things I shouldn't have been eating. That was until my little sister who had a somewhat similar skin type to mine (occasional acne but almost never as bad as mine) ate an entire chocolate orange (6 oz of milk chocolate) by herself one X-mas and had acne for a week after. It was a revelation to me! I'd read that chocolate causing acne was just an unfounded rumor, and I'd rather have believed that! I had been eating chocolate almost all the time! In fact, my first pimple occurred in junior high after eating candy bars. After eliminating chocolate from my diet, I noticed my other nutritional triggers were peanut butter and other nuts (very bad, I'd have acne for several weeks after) and celery seed (also acne would last a week or two).

 

During high school I had tried all sorts of conventional remedies that had almost no effect. I'd gotten a prescription for monocycline that made all my skin dry and reddish yet I still got pimples. I got topical isotretinoin that didn't help either. Of course I tried all the OTC products too (antibacterial soaps, benzoyl peroxide, salcylic acid, sulfur soaps) without much benefit--they might make my skin dry but I still got pimples. So needless to say, when I finally learned how easy it was to avoid acne, I was astounded!

 

It was only after years of avoiding chocolate that I discovered that it was not just any chocolate that affected me but only (cheap) low quality chocolate (especially milk choc and all candy bars) that caused acne in me. I could eat high quality dark chocolate with impunity! The only connection between these diverse foods (chocolate, peanut butter, peanuts, most nuts, celery seed and some other seeds) that I can draw is that the fats are of low quality somehow. The fats in them might be oxidized. Oxidized fats have been shown by many studies to have many deleterious effects in the body (like carcinogenicity!), but the big thing is just that they impair mitochondrial function sapping energy from all cells. This probably makes fat cells in follicles die a necrotic death instead of just lubricating growing hair.

 

Later still, I discovered that the supplement, acetyl-L-carnitine (ALCAR, acylcarnitine, an amino acid in our bodies but only in abundance in red meat) was a cure for my acne no matter what I ate, with one big caveat: I had to take it either before or within a few hours of eating the offending food. If I had it the day after, it would still help, but I'd still get a pimple or two, but at least my oiliness would dry up and the pimple wouldn't be very bad--otherwise I get clusters of pimples all over my body. And amazingly, it only takes the tiniest amount of ALCAR to prevent pimples: 1-5 mg! (Tablets are usually 500 mg!)

 

Now I avoid all my food triggers just because I figure they can't be good for my body anyway, but if I happen to find celery seed was in the cole slaw I got at a restaurant or potluck, I take a tiny amount of ALCAR when I get home, and I don't worry about acne at all.

 

I've noticed peanut butter gives a lot of other people acne, though much more mild than mine was. They tend not to believe me when I tell them their skin would be better without it, but then they do eventually notice that their pimples actually do follow peanut butter.

 

My ethnic background is Irish, German, Scottish, and English with a very tiny bit of Native American. It is mostly only other Irish background people in whom I've noticed peanut butter caused their acne too.

 

I hope this info helps others struggling with acne. I know how bad it felt. It was terribly emotionally scarring and extremely depressing. It made me really resent others with acne at the time. It was so liberating to overcome!

 

I've been so excited to have found this amazing cure for several years now since I discovered it. I try to tell everyone I can. No one needs to suffer with acne even if they don't or can't eat better. It is so easily prevented and treated!

Quote
MemberMember
5
(@chunkylard)

Posted : 04/02/2011 3:09 pm

I think sugar/milk in the chocolate caused your acne, not the "chocolate" itself. Chocolate (cocoa) is quite good for you but if you're buying crappy chocolate it has a LOT of sugar and milk, both of which contribute to acne (the sugar is probably worse than the milk for acne sufferers.)

Quote
MemberMember
1
(@mcmg)

Posted : 04/02/2011 4:37 pm

Well, neither sugar nor milk has ever been a problem for me. I can eat all kinds of terrible sugar with impudence. And I used to drink milk and all milk products: evaporated, condensed, even powder milk on rare occasion, which is what's used in milk chocolate. Milk is not something I've ever had a problem with. But you are right that cocoa powder was another thing I found to not be a problem. Well, I've only had more expensive cocoas in recent years. But cheap dark chocolate (Hershey's "special dark") is still an acne trigger. And actually Ghiradelli white chocolate chips are even something I'm fine with (at least if I've just opened the bag) which is all cocoa butter and powder milk, but not cheap crap.

 

Oh and I forgot to mention trans-fats, which are okay for me in and of themselves (and that crap is in soo many things anymore), but they seem to sensitize me to the effects of the other triggers making the acne worse if it is triggered. And my triggers are: peanuts and various other nuts, esp. roasted; chocolate with cocoa butter except expensive varieties; and some seeds including celery and some kinds of sesame seed, yet never sesame seed oil.

 

I should have added, I've tried many other vitamins and supplements. I found some good effect in various B vitamins particularly B6. But it was never the complete cure that carnitine is (with freedom from all dietary restrictions).

 

But what do you think about the more significant thing I said that acylcarnitine/acetyl-L-carnitine/ALCAR, a common, natural amino acid, is a miraculous cure? It's recommended some places for weight-loss-type problems, but I've never seen its incredible effect on acne mentioned before. So I wanted to bring that info to light if no one's heard it before. Has anyone here had any experience with it? Am I asking in the right place? Acne doesn't have to depend on diet. That's pretty incredible! Everyone should know!

Quote
MemberMember
48
(@dc-girl-3)

Posted : 04/18/2011 3:35 pm

This is amazing, I'm going to try this after I find out for sure what my trigger foods are and then I can see if it works, I hope it does, that would be awesome.

 

Other people should try this, anyone up for the experiment?

This hasn't been tried before by anyone else on the board that I can see............and I agree, if it works, everyone should now!

Quote
MemberMember
1
(@elfgirl)

Posted : 04/18/2011 9:11 pm

So do you take this everyday or just before or after you eat a trigger food like you said? Just curious because I still break out no matter what I do and at my age I really would like to be done with this. I have even gone so far as to keep a food diary and I still don't know sometimes what gets me and sometimes I just have better things to do with my time than write down everyting I put in my mouth! or panic at a friends house or when we go out to eat if I can't find out what is in the food. Elf

Quote
MemberMember
410
(@alternativista)

Posted : 04/19/2011 10:35 am

Sugar is always a problem whether or not you notice any harmful effects from it yet. You will. You need to keep your blood sugar stable.

 

However, fat can be an issue as well. In the past there were a few good discussion threads with people making these claims full of plausible reasoning and good research. But I've never been able to find them again. There have been quite a few studies on diet and various related hormone issues like PCOS and enlarged prostate that showed low fat and low GI diet improved the conditions.

 

Here's what I have gathered on fats: http://www.acne.org/messageboard/Good-Acne...30#entry2637530

 

 

Quote
MemberMember
48
(@dc-girl-3)

Posted : 06/29/2011 8:03 pm

Bump, someone try this!

Quote
MemberMember
48
(@dc-girl-3)

Posted : 12/23/2012 3:14 pm

Anyone ever try this?

Quote