That one gave me an allergic reaction I had the most disgusting, creepy looking eyes for two days. Haha, but I have sensitive eyes... same thing happened with an Almay one.
Anyway, how long is it okay to keep eyeliners for? I swear I've had one for at least 8 months. Sometime when I have eye makeup on I get this feeling like there's something poking my eyes but there's nothing there. So, I think it's just old makeup that's making my eyes feel funky - could it be? I toss out mascara after 2-3