To me it just looks like a mild irratation burn. That happened to me when I scrubbed my face and then put on a mud mask. The calendula should really help. You could it on 10x a day if you want and it would go away faster. You don't have to get just get the ointment either. It comes in a cream or a salve. Really handy stuff to have around. I bet it would be gone in a couple days. If not I'd have it looked at.
Yeah, the eye area can be very sensitive, and perhaps some BP traveled there when moisturizing too. Just keep the area moisturized, and Psychokitty also has some good suggestions for things to try that may be soothing too. Jojoba oil can also help add extra moisture and soothing power if you have any. But the redness should go away, just give it a little time.