I used the regular Cetaphil and it made me break out. I also used Noxzema before, and got a reaction. I have used the Oily skin Cetaphil and I adored it! I had no reactions with it, and it made my skin soft. But I found a better product in Canada. I hope that helps!
Spectrojel is great! It doesn't leave a gross film on your face like Cetaphil. I would recommend the fragrance free one, as the regular Spectrojel's smell made my eyes water...very strong alcohol smell.