I've stumbled on even more research suggesting that disproves the idea that Sebum is such a 'huge/main factor' in acne "Does Facial Sebum Excretion Really Affect the Development of Acne?":
QUOTE
In this study, we measured sebum secretion at five locations on the face to consider regional variations in sebum secretion. In addition, our study incorporates an acne grading system which increases the evaluation accuracy. However, our study has its limitations. The Sebumeter® was used as a measuring tool, and its measurement area is limited to skin contacting the unit's cassette probe. However, the areas in which lesions were counted were larger than this sebum measuring area, and thus there is a possibility of a disparity between the lesion count area and the sebum measuring area.
The absence of correlation between sebum secretion and lesion counts in most facial regions suggests that secreted facial sebum cannot be the only factor inciting the development of acne lesions. Increased sebum secretion is a major component in the pathogenesis of acne, but increased sebum secretion simply increases the likelihood of developing acne lesions, and does not constitute a direct and unique cause of lesion development. For example, the scalp secretes high levels of sebum, but comedogenesis is rarely observed even in patients with severe acne.[13] The present study shows that noninflammatory comedones on the chin, and inflammatory and total lesions in the U-zone, were significantly associated with local sebum secretion. However, their correlation coefficients did not show strong associations, which implies that other factors play an important role in the development of acne in these regions. Increased sebum secretion with follicular obstruction in the same follicle could incite comedogenesis, but increased sebum secretion without follicular obstruction cannot create comedones. Thus, repeated facial washing to remove seborrhoea from the skin surface would not be expected to improve clinical acne. A recent study with orally administered type I 5α-reductase inhibitor, which suppresses facial sebum secretion, showed that the suppression of facial sebum production does not improve acne lesions.[14] This study supports our results.
One more point is worth considering. We performed this study in women, and sebum secretion patterns differ in men and women. Thus there may be a different association between sebum secretion and acne lesion development in men. A further study including males should therefore be performed.
In conclusion, increased facial sebum secretion in women with acne was not found to be the primary cause of acne lesion development, or even of the formation of noninflammatory comedones or inflammatory acne lesions. Rather it is just an epiphenomenon or an aggravating condition in patients with acne. A future study on local androgen receptor variations in follicle openings, which may lead to follicular obstruction, may clarify the association between variations in regional sebum section and acne development.
This work was supported by Seoul National University Bundang Hospital research fund in 2004.
http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/515685I've also been considering "viscosity" of Sebum for possible exacerbation of acne forming. According to acnesource.org:
QUOTE
Sebum is a complex and variable mixture of lipids including:
* Glycerides
* Free fatty acids
* Wax esters
* Squalene
* Cholesterol esters
* Cholesterol
Sebum has the following functions:
* It reduces water loss from the skin surface
* It protects the skin from infection by bacteria and fungi
* It contributes to body odor
* It is colonized by the bacteria Priopionibacterium acnes, which may have a role in immune regulation
For those of us who are more prone to acne by diet, taking a closer look into what foods affect Glyceride, Fatty acids, Wax esters, Squalene, Cholesterol esters, and Cholesterols may help the viscosity of Sebum. However, according to Healthy Skin By Design:
QUOTE
Normally, the cells shedding in the follicle are "flushed" to the surface via various lipid substances exÂcreted in the follicle. In those individuals who are prone to developing acne, a pecu liar change occurs in the manner and pattern in which the dead cells line the follicle. For example, the cells being produced are thicker and sturdier and thus more resistant to the normal "flushing" process of the follicle. Secondly, the cells begin to stick together forming a "kernel" of dead cells. This microscopic kernel is referred to as a microcomedone.
The issue doesn't seem to be Sebum, but rather the formation of this "peculiar change..." in dead cells lining the follicle.
Here's my personal theory. Think about the pore as a fleshy pipe that has clumps of dead cells lining the inside where the dead cells are too clumpy and won't dislodge properly until the very last minute, becoming too large blocking the hole. The Sebum in this case, may have to change it's viscosity to properly "grab" these clumps to flush them out. However what if the clumps of cells are too large to dislodge out of the pore the Sebum would only be a pool party for P.Acne; who is now thriving in an anaerobic environment.
Has anybody else noticed that Acne seems to be a prevalent problem in Western societies? In third world countries where poor children and adults do not have the luxury of fast food or processed food, where are all the people with acne? According to McDougall Newsletter:
QUOTE
Incidence of acne in Western Countries
Adolescents: 79% to 95%
Older than 25: 40% to 54%
Middle aged: 3% to 12%
Incidence of acne in underdeveloped countries: often 0%
Cordain L. Acne vulgaris: a disease of Western civilization. Arch Dermatol. 2002 Dec;138(12):1584-90.
For those of you interested in how to change the keratin process, try looking at underdeveloped countries for an answer. McDougall writes a very interesting article, though old, it cites many sources. His article is titled "Acne Has Nothing to Do with Diet = Wrong!":
http://www.nealhendrickson.com/mcdougall/031100puacne.htmMichael Russell offers us with some insight:
QUOTE
Acne vulgaris is a skin disease that affects between 79% and 95% of the population in America and Europe. Even adult men and women, between 40% and 54% of them, have some kind of acne. After the age of 45, 12% of women and 3% of men still suffer from this affliction.
In the United States there are about 50 million individuals affected by this skin disease. There it is not only present in adolescents, but in children and adults alike. Of those adults older than 25 years 54% of women and 40% of men complain about some kind of acne. About 10% of them battle until late middle age with this problem. These statistics are about the same as those found in studies carried out 20 years ago.
Statistics vary considerably when dealing with children between 10 and 12.Some studies put the number of children suffering from acne in this age group at 30%, whereas other researchers say that it is up to 60%. There is less discrepancy however when dealing with adolescents who are between 16 and 18 years old. Studies agree that the percentage there lies between 79% to 95%.
In Caucasian populations even a significant number of children between 4 and 7 years of age are in medical treatment because of acne. It is therefore clear that acne is a widespread disease in light-skinned societies, where it not only affects young children and adolescents, but a significant portion of people 25 years and older.
In African and Asian societies there are far less people, adolescents or adults alike, that have some kind of facial acne: only 2%. This is not so only because of hereditary factors. The generally more polluted environments in America and Europe play an important role in the far higher incidence of facial acne in Western societies.
Even though there are only a few studies that deal with acne in underdeveloped societies the results in this research show that acne is far more prevalent in industrialized nations. This is most likely due to dietary habits. People in the West are very fond of dairy products, of alcohol, coffee and tea, products rich in fat like margarine and cooking oils, cereals and sugar, all of which are detrimental to health when eaten in excess. People in Africa or South America, for example, eat far more fruit and vegetables, have a lower fat intake and eat more food with a higher percentage of carbohydrates.
Studies carried out in South Africa, for example, showed that the incidence of acne was far lower in the Bantu population than among whites. Both ethnic groups reside in the area of Pretoria. Only 16% of Bantu adolescents suffered from acne whereas 45% of the white teenagers were afflicted with it. Taking into consideration all age groups in this sample, only 2% of the natives had acne, compared to 10% of the whites. Among other tribes it was suggested that acne as a widespread problem only surfaced when those people left their rural villages and moved closer to urbanized areas or cities.
Since the early 1980s a lot of evidence has been gathered that demonstrates that native populations getting in contact with Western civilization usually suffer from an overall health perspective and this is definitely true in the case of skin diseases such as acne.
http://ezinearticles.com/?Acne-in-Underdev...s&id=234666Perhaps the "peculiar change" in the lining of our pores have to do with diet. None the less I still want to find ways to deal with this peculiar change topically. So, my search for information continues...
Sources:
http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/515685http://www.healthyskinbydesign.com/acne.cfmhttp://www.acnesource.org/facts_what-causes-acne_oil.htmhttp://www.nealhendrickson.com/mcdougall/031100puacne.htmhttp://ezinearticles.com/?Acne-in-Underdev...s&id=234666