I use this product 1-3 times a week. I haven't seen much improvement, however it does reduce the redness of a spot.
I continued to use this because its very soothing and cooling and seems to make a slight positive improvement to my skin (no breakouts!)
Pros: Refreshes, soothes, cools. Reduces spot redness.
Cons: Does not get rid of spots, messy (as are they all), container can be contaminated.
Recommend? Again, if you're willing to spend a little more money, this product may be for you. However I've read other reviews that this product did nothing for them and for some, it broke them out. I would recommend it for its cooling properties, but not as a spot treatment.