A more natural way to combat acne

In the past couple weeks, I've developed mild-moderate acne all over my forehead. It's extremely red and inflamed. I've tried using benzoyl peroxide face wash along with a benzoyl peroxide gel, but my skin is so sensitive and it just made my skin more inflamed. I was also using 2% salycic acid pads. I followed this regimen for a few days but like I said, it just made my poor skin more inflamed. So I switched to more natural ways to fight this horrible acne on my forehead. At night, I use a face wash with tea tree oil, moist pads with tea tree oil, and a moisturizer with witch hazel. I also use this blemish stick that contains tree tree oil. In the morning, I use a natural cleanser and acne gel, along with the witch hazel moisturizer. I'm hoping this new regimen will be nicer on my skin. I'd like to know if anyone else with sensitive skin has this problem and what they did to combat it. Here's the list of products that I use:

Morning

Lush Herbalism facial cleanser
Lush Coalface facial cleanser
Lush Vanishing Cream facial moisturizer
Nelson's Pure and Clear Acne Gel (with tea tree oil and sulfur)



Night
Desert Essence Thoroughly Clean Face Wash with organic Tea Tree Oil and Awapuli
Desert Essence Natural Tea Tree Oil Facial Cleansing Pads
Aura Cacia Cleansing Tea Tree stick
Lush Vanishing Cream facial moisturizer